Faculty Seminar | Nigam Nuggehalli and Ashrita Prasad Kotha
Allen & Overy Conference Room, First Floor, Training Centre
Wednesday, November 18, 2026, 3:45 pm
This faculty seminar will feature a presentation by Dr. Nigam Nuggehalli, Professor (Law), and Dr. Ashrita Prasad Kotha, Associate Professor (Law), on ‘Indian Tax Law Scholarship: Finding Principle Amid Fiction.’
Abstract
The authors seek to answer two questions in this chapter. The first question pertains to the place of tax law scholarship within legal scholarship, more broadly. One of the unique challenges faced by tax law scholarship is the difficulty in identifying the animating principles that inform the statutory provisions. The authors argue that one needs to appreciate the structural foundations of tax law in order to better understand the normativity inherent in the statutory provisions of tax law. The second question relates to concerns particularly acute in India. The authors contend that Indian tax law scholarship has the peculiar problem that it must find a way to survive the deeming fiction overload across the breadth of the statutes. Deeming fictions in the Indian income tax law range from the addition of artificial categories to income to carving out various exceptions to the schedular system. An excessive use of deeming fictions threatens the structural integrity of tax legislation.