News Type: Event

This Wednesday, there will be a discussion about the India Justice Report (IJR) by Maja Daruwala, the Chief Editor, and Valay Singh, the project lead of IJR. Brief note about the IJR and previous reports are attached to this email.

About the Speakers: 

1.Valay Singh is the project lead of the India Justice Report. Valay Singh has worked in the development sector over the last 10 years, having been a media professional previously. His interests lie in issues of civil and political liberties, women and child rights, mainstreaming the narrative on justice, freedom of speech and expression and politics and religion. Valay is also the author of Ayodhya: City of faith, City of discord, published by Aleph Book Company.

2.Maja  Daruwala is the Chief Editor of the India Justice Report. A barrister from Lincoln’s Inn, she has been working to advocate for rights and social justice for over 40 years. She is actively engaged in numerous human rights initiatives and concentrates on issues relating to civil liberties including police reform, prison reform, right to information, discrimination, women’s rights, freedom of expression and human rights advocacy capacity building. Ms Daruwala’s interests lie particularly in the area of systemic reforms. She has focused her energies on issues of accountability and participation, which she believes are essential underpinnings for good governance and the realisation of human rights. She sits on several charitable boards including the Population Foundation of India and Centre for Social Justice. She was earlier the director of Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative and a Senior Adviser for the Tata Trusts.

 

 

On Friday, 11th August, 2023, Mr. Vikram Raghavan, NLS BA LLB 1997, will be presenting a talk on ‘Coups & Constitutions’. Vikram is the Lead Counsel at World Bank, Washington DC.

In this presentation, Vikram will focus on constitutional crises in countries ranging from Afghanistan, Myanmar, Sudan, and Niger. These crises arise from military coups, contested elections, and other extra-constitutional changes in governments. He will explore the international legal dimensions of these crises and examine how states and international organizations respond to these crises. Prof. Aparna Chandra will be the discussant.

About the speaker:

Vikram’s work covers a wide range of subjects: the Bank’s mandate and its Articles of Agreement, loan conditionality, post-conflict reconstruction, refugees and forced displacement, humanitarian crises, coups, sanctions, contractual disputes, expropriation, graduation, and sovereign debt. In over two-decades of his career at the Bank, he has worked on projects in many countries. They include Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran, India, Mali, Myanmar, Nepal, Pakistan, Philippines, Somalia, South Sudan, Sri Lanka, Yemen, and the West Bank and Gaza. He also works on legal and policy issues arising from the Bank’s engagements in countries affected by conflict, fragility, and violence. He  was a team member for the Bank’s flagship publication, the 2011 World Development Report Conflict, Security, and Development. He is also part of the team for the 2023 World Development Report on migration and forced displacement. He received the Bank’s Bretton Woods@75
award for his contributions to preserving the Bank’s institutional memory.

Before the World Bank, he was an associate at New York office of the international law firm, O’Melveny and Myers. He also co-founded the legal blog Law and Other Things. He is an active member of the American Society of International Law and has served on its executive council. He is particularly passionate about mentoring law students and junior lawyers and spends part of his vacation each year visiting new law schools to talk to students.

Published Work: His first book was Communications Law in India (2006) which has been cited by the Supreme Court of India. He has co-edited Comparative Constitutionalism in South Asia (2010) a collection of essays by leading scholars. More recently, he edited George Gadbois’s Supreme Court of India: The Beginnings (2017). He is presently working on a narrative history of how India emerged as a constitutional republic in 1950.

This is a closed-doors event and open to the NLS community only.

 

This week’s faculty seminar will be held on 9 August, 2023. Prof. Nanditta Batra will be presenting a paper titled ‘Bail on Medical Grounds in India: A Search for Principled Jurisprudence’. Prof. Nagaratna will be the discussant.

Abstract

The law creates a leeway for sick and infirm persons to obtain bail in otherwise hard cases due to their vulnerable position. However, the provision of obtaining bail on medical grounds has been under immense public scrutiny as it has been often observed that the accused with political patronage find it a convenient route to regain their liberty while others continue to languish in jail despite their precarious health conditions. Such a situation is an enigma to ‘Rule of Law’. In order to understand whether such an anomaly actually exists and the reasons for such anomaly, if any, I attempt to first systematically sketch the basic principles of law that the Courts must adhere to in adjudicating bail cases on medical grounds. I then map the actual practices of the Indian Courts and the degree of coherence in following a particular principle by empirically examining the data from cases decided between January2020 to August 2023.

This week’s faculty seminar will be held on 2 August, 2023. Prof (Dr.) Nigam Nuggehalli will be discussing about the topic titled ‘Tax Avoidance in Indian Tax Treaties: The Past, the Present and the Future’.

Abstract

Extract from the ‘Introduction’: “This chapter discusses the nature of tax avoidance with reference to Indian tax treaty provisions and various measures, legislative and judicial, undertaken to engage with such tax avoidance. A particular focus of the chapter is on broad spectrum anti-avoidance rules, popularly known as General Anti-Avoidance Rules in the domestic context and the Principal Purpose clause (the PPT clause) in the context of tax treaties.”

Our next public lecture will take place on 3rd August 2023. Our guest speaker is Prof. Ruth Vanita who will be delivering a talk titled “Translating Gender and Sexuality”.

About the Speaker:

Ruth Vanita is the author, most recently, of two novels, Memory of Light (Penguin 2022) and A Slight Angle (forthcoming Penguin 2024) and The Broken Rainbow: Poems and Translations (Copper Coin 2023). Her books include The Dharma of Justice in the Sanskrit Epics: Debates on Gender, Varna and Species (Oxford University Press, 2022) Love’s Rite: Same-Sex Marriages in Modern India (Penguin 2005; 2023); Gender, Sex and the City: Urdu Rekhti Poetry 1780-1870; and ‘A Woman More Worth than any Man’: History and Vision in Nine Shakespeare Plays (forthcoming 2024). Her book, On the Edge: A Hundred Years of Hindi Fiction on Same-Sex Desire will appear from Penguin in August 2023. She co-edited the path-breaking Same-Sex Love in India, and has translated several works of fiction and poetry from Hindi to English, including Chocolate, Ugra’s 1927 collection of stories on male homosexuality, and Mahadevi Varma’s My Family. She divides her time between Missoula and Gurgaon.

Abstract:

This talk examines the shades of difference between translating non-fiction, fiction, and poetry from Hindi and Urdu to English and fiction from English to Hindi, especially with regard to words and idioms relating to romantic and erotic feeling and experience. “I consider the gendering of verbs and pronouns, the way Bombay film songs manage to avoid both in a way that English cannot, the way Urdu poetry teases the reader with ambiguities that sometimes are untranslatable, and the way my own poetry addresses issues of translation in its original sense (moving from one space and time to another) as well as its more specific sense with regard to languages.”

The next faculty seminar will be held on 26 July, 2023. Ms. Ishika Saxena will be discussing the paper titled ‘Deconstructing the Universal of Consent’. Prof (Dr.) Rinku Lamba will be the discussant.

Abstract

This paper will argue that the normative model of understanding sexual violence requires expansion and reworking to account for the full complexity of this nature of this violence. This normative model characterizes sexual assault by the presence or absence of consent.

This notion of consent operates as a universal which does not account for several particulars such as persons who may not be able to consent. Such particulars may be cultural specificities, socio-political conditions of inequality, as well as the inaccessibility of freedom to most people. This paper wishes to extrapolate the role of equality and freedom in how ‘ideal’ consent is understood. Hegemonic (such as social practices) and institutional elements (such as the law) intersect to produce this current understanding of sexual violence.

This paper focuses on deconstructing consent by focusing on two such particulars; queerness and disability. Queerness is unaccounted for by the logic of the definition of rape which when positioned as the gravest form of sexual harm, assumes that harm is caused by a penis-bearing individual in all cases. Within the legal definitions of this framework, there is an assumption of a giver-recipient dynamic to sexual intercourse, which is a heterosexual presumption. Alongside this, the question of disability becomes relevant at the conceptual level as it elucidates the theoretical limitations of the notion of freedom, i.e., free will.

The consent framework of sexual assault is an oversimplification of a complex problem. These particulars affect how consent plays out in actual practice. The inadequacy of the universal is elucidated through the particulars that are unaccounted for by this universal. It is therefore necessary to ask if this is the best universal for understanding sexual assault. “

This week’s faculty seminar will be presented by Devyani Srivastava and Laksha on their research titled ” “Status of Women in the Karnataka State Police”.

Abstract

This report presents findings from an assessment conducted by the National Law School of India University (NLSIU) on the status and role of policewomen in Karnataka. The state government is working to increase women’s representation in its police from existing 8 percent to 25 percent. Given this, the study aims to provide an evidence base for institutional reform needed to ensure a supportive environment for policewomen. It does this in three ways: one, by highlighting patterns and shortfalls in women’s deployment across ranks, districts, units and roles; two, identifying factors (social, cultural and institutional) that are either impeding women’s performance or driving their growth within the institution; and three, measuring gaps in views among officers, mainly female, on the importance of women in policing. It is hoped the findings will inform and augment the department’s ongoing efforts and planning to make sure women not just join the police service but are able to participate meaningfully at all levels. The study also seeks to contribute to the growing research on gender and policing emanating from the global south and further diversify police reform discourse taking place both within the country and globally.

This week faculty seminar on 12 July, 2023 will feature a discussion on the paper titled ‘Reflections on Rabindranath Tagore’s Religion of Man’ by  Prof. (Dr.) Rinku Lamba.

Abstract

“Charles Taylor’s scholarship on the social imaginary of the modern west — in terms of a vision of moral order anchored in notions of equality, economy, and self-government, as well as a conception of the public sphere — is important for many reasons. It illustrates a ‘cultural’ approach to comprehend modernity, which Taylor himself endorses, as compared to an ‘a cultural’ understanding of modernity that views the phenomenon as linked predominantly to material changes in society that can be replicated in different parts of the world wherever similar material changes are ushered. Further, and consistent with ideas about multiple and alternative modernities, Taylor’s work inspires interrogations of the contents of the social imaginaries that sustain modernity in other jurisdictions, including India. Such interrogations will entail studies of doctrines, symbols and embodied practices all of which, according to Taylor, are sites for comprehending the vision of moral order that anchors a social imaginary.

To contribute to the emerging scholarship about the vision of moral order that anchors Indian modernity, and this paper is part of that broader task. Admittedly, the task involved requires work by a whole community of scholars, and I cannot pretend to provide some overarching answer to questions about what constitutes that vision of moral order. But I wish to focus on the political thought of Rabindranath Tagore – as a doctrinal site – to contribute to the larger task of delineating the particular understandings of religion (with respect to themes of hierarchy, self-rule, independence, state-society relationship) that anchor the vision of moral order underpinning the social imaginaries of modern India.”

The first public lecture for 2023-24 will take place on 13 July 2023. Our first guest speaker is Dr. Prachi Deshpande who will be delivering a talk titled “The Modi Script, Writing, and the Marathi Language in History” based on her recently published book, Scripts of Power: Writing, Language Practices, and Cultural History in Western India (Orient Blackswan, 2023).

About the Speaker

Dr. Prachi Deshpande is Associate Professor of History at the Centre for Studies in Social Sciences, Calcutta. Her interests are in historiography, memory studies, language historiography, and regional politics. She is the author of Creative Pasts: Historical Memory and Identity in western India (2007) and of Scripts of Power: Writing, Language Practices, and Cultural History in Western India (2023).

Abstract

A cursive script called Modi (moḍī) was in use from the fifteenth century to write in Marathi. Modi’s usage expanded under the medieval Sultanat and early modern Maratha kingdoms within a broad di-graphia: literati used Balbodh (a variant of today’s Devanagari script) for literary and sacred texts, and Modi for letters and revenue records (which were frequently bilingual, with Persian). In the nineteenth century, print technology favoured Balbodh, as it could render a larger range of phonemes current in Marathi speech, and Modi usage gradually declined. Devanagari is today the official script used to write Marathi, even though recent years have seen a resurgence in the interest in Modi. Overall, the story of the Modi script usually appears as a ‘lack,’ ‘deviation’ or afterthought from the story of Marathi language history proper, even though it has great symbolic value as a visual icon of the early modern Maratha state. In this talk, drawing on my recently published book Scripts of Power, I focus on the practice, usage, and changing meanings and deployments of the Modi script to probe the interplay between writing, script, and language and its relationship to bureaucratic and social power. I am interested in how a now-marginal and infrequently-used script like Moḍī can tell us about social and regional power and identity, and offer fresh ways to think about language history.

The Centre for Environmental Law, Education, Research and Advocacy (CEERA), NLSIU and the Department of Justice, Ministry of Law and Justice, GoI, is organising the second Prof. V. S. Mallar Memorial Legal Aid Competition from July-October 2023. This competition is organised as part of the pan India Legal Literacy and Legal Awareness Programme.

About the Competition

The Legal Aid Clinic Competition shall be a 4 (four) month-pronged Competition. Further, access to legal education is a necessary corollary to the right of free legal aid. With the advancement of digital technologies, this right has become all the more accessible. Legal aid clinics, particularly those functioning under the aegis of educational institutions, play a pivotal role in improving community access to legal information and education and in engaging the youth in mass literacy dissemination efforts.

The endeavor of the second edition of this Competition is to further augment and strengthen the activities of the legal aid cells across the country to spread essential legal awareness by conducting awareness drives and various other creative initiatives and campaigns to bring to the fore the presence of informational asymmetry contributing
directly to the lack of legal awareness.

The competition shall comprise six core deliverables which shall include:

• ACCESS TO LEGAL AID: PRISON CLINIC
• LOK ADALAT
• ENGAGEMENT WITH STREET VENDORS
• SPEED MENTORING
• NON-PROFIT PARTNERING
• FINAL REPORT

For more details on the competition and the deliverables, please read the brochure.

Awards & Prizes

Winners – Best Legal Aid Clinic – INR 25,000
First Runners Up – Best Legal Aid Clinic – INR 20,000
Second Runners Up – Best Legal Aid Clinic – INR 15,000
Best Faculty Coordinator award – INR 10,000
Best All India Legal Aid Clinic Student Lawyers – INR 10,000

Who can register for the competition

The Legal Aid Competition is open to all clubs and legal aid Clinics/committees housed in any institute.
We encourage Management, Commerce institutions also to partake in this competition. NSS, NCC,
Scouts Units are also encouraged to participate in this competition.

Team Composition

The representatives of the participating institutions for all purposes and for the entire duration of the competition shall comprise the following:

• 1 Faculty Coordinator/Advisor/NCC/NSS Officer
• 1 Student Coordinator
• Maximum of 8 other students, who will formulate the Core Team
• Other Students, whose participation may be certified by the Participating Institution

Registration Details

The registration fee for a team is INR 5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand Only).
Institutions interested in participating in the competition may register by filling in the Google form here.
The last date to register has been extended to June 30, 2023.